Environmental injustice in journalism: Analysis of pesticide pollution reporting

Por Ilza Maria Tourinho Girardi, Débora Gallas Steigleder, Jamille Almeida da Silva, Eloisa Beling Loose

Article ID: 2012
Vol 4, Issue 2, 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.54517/ps.v4i2.2012
Received: 01 November 2023; Accepted: 27 November 2023; Available online: 09 December 2023;
Issue release: 12 December 2023

VIEWS - 7776 (Abstract)

Download PDF

Abstract

The objective of this paper is to discuss the approach of the journalism on the use of pesticides as a situation that generates environmental injustice. To make such reflection, we rely on the series of Zero Hora reports published in December 2016 on the contamination of Ceasa products, in Porto Alegre, by pesticides banned in Rio Grande do Sul (Brazil) or used above the limit set by law. We start from Acselrad’s (2010) conception of environmental justice. This is a notion that refers to socio-political dynamics, since it includes conflicts arising from the violation of the rights of human communities due to unsustainable use of the environment. To assess the impact of injustices in the media, we resorted to the assumptions of Environmental Journalism, a perspective that defends the mobilizing function of journalism based on a complex view of the phenomena (Girardi et al., 2012) from a descriptive and qualitative analysis (Martins, 2001). Among the results, it is noted that the series does not incorporate a systemic view of the problem, ignoring the impacts of pesticides on the entire production chain and ecosystems.


Keywords

environmental journalism, environmental justice, pesticides, Zero Hora, news coverage, pesticides


References

1. INCA. Position of the José Alencar Gomes da Silva National Cancer Institute on agrotoxics (Portuguese). Available online: http://www1.inca.gov.br/inca/Arquivos/comunicacao/posicionamento_do_inca_sobre_os_agrotoxicos_06_abr_15.pdf (accessed on 2 June 2022).

2. Acselrad H. Environmentalization of social struggles - the case of the environmental justice movement (Portuguese). Estudos Avançados. 2010; 24(68): 103-119. doi: 10.1590/s0103-40142010000100010

3. Girardi IMT. Paths and byways of Environmental Journalism (Portuguese). C&S. 2012; 34(1): 131-152.

4. Martins J. Qualitative research (Portuguese). In: Fazenda I. (editor). Metodologia da pesquisa educacional. São Paulo: Cortez; 2001. pp. 47-58.

5. Gil AC. Social research methods and techniques (Portuguese). São Paulo: Atlas; 2008.

6. Carneiro, F. Food and nutrition security and health (Portuguese). In: Carneiro F, Augusto L, Rigotto R, et al. (editors). Dossiê ABRASCO: um alerta sobre os impactos dos agrotóxicos na saúde. Rio de Janeiro: EPSJV; 2015.

7. Lutzenberger JA. Ecological foundations of organic farming (Portuguese). In: Curso de Agricultura Biológica. Porto Alegre: SARGS/Assembleia Legislativa do Rio Grande do Sul; 1981. pp. 52-71.

8. Girardi IMT. Agricultural journals and the ideology of agricultural modernization (Portuguese) [Master’s thesis]. Instituto Metodista de Ensino Superior; 1988.

9. Brum A. Modernization of agriculture: wheat and soya (Portuguese). Ijuí: Fidene/Unijuí; 1985.

10. Pinheiro S. Back to the future (Portuguese). In: Pinheiro, S. (editor). Agropecuária sem veneno. Porto Alegre: L± 1985. pp. 99-144.

11. Facchini LA, Souza LE, Apresentação. ABRASCO dossier: a warning about the health impacts of pesticides (Portuguese). São Paulo: Expressão Popular. 2015; 37-40.

12. CNA. Kátia Abreu charges agility in the release of agricultural defensives. Available online: http://senadorakatiaabreu.com.br/katia-abreu-cobra-agilidade-na-liberacao-de-defensivos-agricolas (accessed on 2 June 2022).

13. Romano RT. (2016) Os agrotóxicos e os produtos fitossanitários. Available online: https://jus.com.br/artigos/50472 (accessed on 2 June 2022).

14. Petersen P. ABRASCO dossier: a warning about the health impacts of pesticides (Portuguese). São Paulo: Expressão Popular. 2015; 27-36.

15. History of Organic Agriculture: some considerations. Available online: http://planetaorganico.com.br/ site/index.php/historia-da-agricultura-organica-algumas-consideracoes/ (accessed on 2 June 2022).

16. Portal B. Agricultura orgânica deve movimentar R$ 2,5 bi em 2016. Available online: http://www.brasil.gov. br/economia-e-emprego/2015/10/agricultura-organica- deve-movimentar-r-2-5-bi-em-2016 (accessed on 2 June 2022).

17. Herculano S. The cry for environmental justice and against environmental racism (Portuguese). InterfacEHS. 2008; 3(1): 1-20.

18. Girardi IMT, Loose EB, Camana A. Overview of Environmental Journalism research in Brazil: the state of the art in dissertations and theses between 1987 and 2010 (Portuguese). Porto Alegre, UFRGS; 2015.

19. Bueno W. Communication, journalism and the environment: theory and research (Portuguese). São Paulo: Majoara; 2007.

20. Bueno WDC. Environmental journalism: exploring beyond the concept (Portuguese). Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente. 2007; 15. doi: 10.5380/dma.v15i0.11897

21. Bacchetta V. Planetary citizenship (Portuguese). Montevideo: International Federation of Environmental Journalists; 2000.

22. Gil AC. How to design a documentary survey (Portuguese)? In: Gil AC. (editor). Como elaborar projetos de pesquisa. São Paulo, Atlas; 2002. pp. 87-92.

23. Grupo de Investigação RBS. Danger on the plate: invisible evil (Portuguese). Jornal Zero Hora. 2016; 6-13.

24. Grupo de Investigação RBS. Danger on the plate: smuggling into RS (Portuguese). Jornal Zero Hora. 2016; 24-27.

25. Grupo de Investigação RBS. Danger on the plate: your health at risk (Portuguese). Jornal Zero Hora. 2016; 10-16.

26. Gelós HS. Environmental Journalism: communicational axis of the XXI century. Jornalismo Ambiental: desafios e reflexões. 2008; 67-74.

27. Grupo de Investigação RBS. Danger on the plate: Pernambuco—agreement reduces food contamination (Portuguese). Jornal Zero Hora. 2016; 24-25.

28. Grupo de Investigação RBS. Danger on the plate: MP and police to investigate pesticide abuse (Portuguese). Jornal Zero Hora. 2016; 32-33.

29. Girardi IMT, Schwaab RT. Challenges and reflections (Portuguese). Jornalismo Ambiental. 2008.

30. Primavesi O. Food production collides with the environment because it suffers from greed (Portuguese). Formação & Informação Ambiental: jornalismo para iniciados e leigos. 2004; 177-201.

31. Loose EB, Girardi IMT. Environmental journalism from the perspective of climate risks. Ínterin Magazine (Portuguese). 2017; 22(2): 154-172.

32. Frome M. Green Ink: an introduction to Environmental Journalism (Portuguese). Curitiba: Editora UFPR; 2008.

33. Garcia R. About the earth: a guide for those who read and write about the environment (Portuguese). Lisbon: Público; 2006.

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2023 Por Ilza Maria Tourinho Girardi, Débora Gallas Steigleder, Jamille Almeida da Silva, Eloisa Beling Loose

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


This site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).